Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Review: Bellman and Black by Diane Setterfield

Bellman & Black

Review by Shellie for Bellman & Black by Diane Setterfield

Shellie’s quick take:  Set in England in the 1800’s, in a Yorkshire mill town and on the outskirts of London, this literary thriller has a dark, otherworldly, and mysterious thread with a hidden moral. It also includes facts and mythology about the Rook woven through its story-line.

Shellie’s description:  Bellman & Black is primarily about the life of the main character, William Bellman. It begins on a fateful day when the youthful William kills a Rook (a crow of sorts found mostly in Europe) during a moment of bravado in front of a group of his amazed friends - via a lucky catapult from his slingshot. This unlikely once-in-a-lifetime strike turns out to be an example of the luck and success of William’s life. In addition to being lucky, he is handsome and driven, and the world appears to open its arms for the young man.

But like every human, life delivers William Bellman the hard knocks that are unavoidable. It is during one of these periods that he encounters Mr. Black - a man who is to become for William the metaphor for the one thing that he cannot escape.

Shellie’s thoughts:  This is a gothic-like literary thriller. Although technically not a gothic novel, it has some aspects that make it feel like it is - for example there is that dark, moody feel to the tone of of the story. And because it is a literary novel from an established author, there is definitely strong character development. I found myself knowing and understanding the main character quite well. There is also a great plot with interesting ups and down throughout, including a light paranormal thread. Happily I found myself wondering what was going to happen next, including some nice chills every so often, that will appeal to horror fans.

I liked that the author uses lovely period-styled prose, though paradoxically she kept it modern-ish, giving the book an authentic feel without the difficulty of having to decipher the old-fashioned writing style often found in Victorian literature. I definitely liked this particular aspect of the novel, which is perfect for anyone who enjoys historical fiction.

Recommended for anyone interested in literary thrillers and horror, those who enjoy a gothic feel to their reads, readers interested in a light paranormal element, and anyone who is interested in historical England. I would also recommend it to readers interested in birds. A terrific and well-written book, the author has apparently taken years to complete it and it shows. It’s highly recommended at 4 stars.


Atria/Emily Bestler Books |  336 pages |  November 2013

For more information about Bellman & Black you can take a look at our Incoming Books post for November 8, 2013 including it.

6 comments:

Jenny @ Reading the End said...

To readers interested in birds, really? Is it that bird-heavy? I hadn't heard that anywhere else, and it makes me more interested than I was. It talks about rooks?

Shellie Nunn said...

Hi Jenny -
Yes the author uses the mythology and some interesting facts around the rook. It's mostly symbolism, but it's an important theme.

I'm very surprised that to hear that the use of the bird isn't mentioned in any of the reviews you've seen elsewhere.

I'd be interested to see what you think about the book, if you decide to read it.

Carl V. Anderson said...

I need to get back to this one. I started reading it when it came out and then got distracted. I loved her first novel, The Thirteenth Tale. It remains one of my favorites.

Shellie Nunn said...

Hi Carl -
I've had - The Thirteenth Tale - on my TBR list for years now, so I was very happy to receive this book in the mail.

Happily, - Bellman & Black - was one of those novels that kept me reading (which does not happen often for me). I have a tendency to abandon books regularly in the first chapter or about a third of the way through.

It is a well written book, so it comes recommended. So if you are one of those readers who can pick up a book after it's been sitting for awhile I hope you enjoy it!

ChristasBooks said...

"gothic style literary thriller" sounds fascinating! I've heard good things about this author so I will definitely check this out

Shellie Nunn said...

Hi Christa -
It's a great book and I think that you will like it.I read it in a few days so you should breeze through it. I will keep a look out to see what your thoughts are.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...